A Bibliometric Framework for Identifying “Princes” Who Wake up the “Sleeping Beauty” in Challenge-type Scientific Discoveries
Jian Du1,2; Yishan Wu3; Yishan Wu (E-mail: wuyishan@istic.ac.cn).
2016-03-17
Source PublicationJournal of Data and Information Science
Volume9Issue:1Pages:50-68
Other Abstract

Purpose: This paper develops and validates a bibliometric framework for identifying the “princes” (PR) who wake up the “sleeping beauty” (SB) in challenge-type scientific discoveries, so as to figure out the awakening mechanisms, and promote potentially valuable but not readily accepted innovative research. (A PR is a research study.)

Design/methodology/approach: We propose that PR candidates must meet the following four criteria: (1) be published near the time when the SB began to attract a lot of citations; (2) be highly cited papers themselves; (3) receive a substantial number of co-citations with the SB; and (4) within the challenge-type discoveries which contradict established theories, the “pulling effect” of the PR on the SB must be strong. We test the usefulness of the bibliometric framework through a case study of a key publication by the 2014 chemistry Nobel laureate Stefan W. Hell, who negated Ernst Abbe's diffraction limit theory, one of the most prominent paradigms in the natural sciences.

Findings: The first-ranked candidate PR article identified by the bibliometric framework is in line with historical facts. An SB may need one or more PRs and even “retinues” to be “awakened.” Documents with potential awakening functionality tend to be published in prestigious multidisciplinary journals with higher impact and wider scope than the journals publishing SBs.

Research limitations: The above framework is only applicable to transformative innovations, and the conclusions are drawn from the analysis of one typical SB and her awakening process. Therefore the generality of our work might be limited.

Practical implications: Publications belonging to so-called transformative research, even when less frequently cited, should be given special attention as early as possible, because they may suddenly attract many citations after a period of sleep, as reflected in our case study. in Challenge-type Scientific Discoveries http://www.jdis.org

Originality/value>: The definition of PR(s) as the first paper(s) that cited the SB article (selfciting excluded) has its limitations. Instead, the SB-PR co-citations should be given priority in current environment of scholarly communication. Since the “premature” or “transformative” breakthroughs in the challenge-type SB documents are either beyond the current knowledge domain, or violate established paradigms, people's psychological distance from the SB is larger than that from the PR, which explains why the annual citations of the PR are usually higher than those of the SB, especially prior to or during the SB's citation boom period.

;

Purpose: This paper develops and validates a bibliometric framework for identifying the “princes” (PR) who wake up the “sleeping beauty” (SB) in challenge-type scientific discoveries, so as to figure out the awakening mechanisms, and promote potentially valuable but not readily accepted innovative research. (A PR is a research study.)

Design/methodology/approach: We propose that PR candidates must meet the following four criteria: (1) be published near the time when the SB began to attract a lot of citations; (2) be highly cited papers themselves; (3) receive a substantial number of co-citations with the SB; and (4) within the challenge-type discoveries which contradict established theories, the “pulling effect” of the PR on the SB must be strong. We test the usefulness of the bibliometric framework through a case study of a key publication by the 2014 chemistry Nobel laureate Stefan W. Hell, who negated Ernst Abbe's diffraction limit theory, one of the most prominent paradigms in the natural sciences.

Findings: The first-ranked candidate PR article identified by the bibliometric framework is in line with historical facts. An SB may need one or more PRs and even “retinues” to be “awakened.” Documents with potential awakening functionality tend to be published in prestigious multidisciplinary journals with higher impact and wider scope than the journals publishing SBs.

Research limitations: The above framework is only applicable to transformative innovations, and the conclusions are drawn from the analysis of one typical SB and her awakening process. Therefore the generality of our work might be limited.

Practical implications: Publications belonging to so-called transformative research, even when less frequently cited, should be given special attention as early as possible, because they may suddenly attract many citations after a period of sleep, as reflected in our case study. in Challenge-type Scientific Discoveries
http://www.jdis.org

Originality/value>: The definition of PR(s) as the first paper(s) that cited the SB article (selfciting excluded) has its limitations. Instead, the SB-PR co-citations should be given priority in current environment of scholarly communication. Since the “premature” or “transformative” breakthroughs in the challenge-type SB documents are either beyond the current knowledge domain, or violate established paradigms, people's psychological distance from the SB is larger than that from the PR, which explains why the annual citations of the PR are usually higher than those of the SB, especially prior to or during the SB's citation boom period.

SubtypeResearch Papers
KeywordCitation History Delayed Recognition Awakening Mechanisms Transformative Innovation Nobel Prize
Subject Area新闻学与传播学 ; 图书馆、情报与文献学
DOI10.20309/jdis.201605
URL查看原文
Indexed By其他
Project NumberGrant No.: 71373252 ; Grant No.: 14R0106
Language英语
Funding ProjectThis study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China ; the Project from Institute of Medical Information of Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences
Citation statistics
Document Type期刊论文
Identifierhttp://ir.las.ac.cn/handle/12502/8478
CollectionJournal of Data and Information Science_Journal of Data and Information Science-2016
Corresponding AuthorYishan Wu (E-mail: wuyishan@istic.ac.cn).
Affiliation1.School of Information Management, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210032, China
2.Institute of Medical Information & Library, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences, Beijing 100005, China
3.Chinese Academy of Science and Technology for Development, Beijing 100038, China
First Author Affilication中国科学院文献情报中心
Recommended Citation
GB/T 7714
Jian Du,Yishan Wu,Yishan Wu (E-mail: wuyishan@istic.ac.cn).. A Bibliometric Framework for Identifying “Princes” Who Wake up the “Sleeping Beauty” in Challenge-type Scientific Discoveries[J]. Journal of Data and Information Science,2016,9(1):50-68.
APA Jian Du,Yishan Wu,&Yishan Wu .(2016).A Bibliometric Framework for Identifying “Princes” Who Wake up the “Sleeping Beauty” in Challenge-type Scientific Discoveries.Journal of Data and Information Science,9(1),50-68.
MLA Jian Du,et al."A Bibliometric Framework for Identifying “Princes” Who Wake up the “Sleeping Beauty” in Challenge-type Scientific Discoveries".Journal of Data and Information Science 9.1(2016):50-68.
Files in This Item: Download All
File Name/Size DocType Version Access License
20160105.pdf(2578KB)期刊论文出版稿开放获取CC BY-NC-NDView Download
Related Services
Recommend this item
Bookmark
Usage statistics
Export to Endnote
Google Scholar
Similar articles in Google Scholar
[Jian Du]'s Articles
[Yishan Wu]'s Articles
[Yishan Wu (E-mail: wuyishan@istic.ac.cn).]'s Articles
Baidu academic
Similar articles in Baidu academic
[Jian Du]'s Articles
[Yishan Wu]'s Articles
[Yishan Wu (E-mail: wuyishan@istic.ac.cn).]'s Articles
Bing Scholar
Similar articles in Bing Scholar
[Jian Du]'s Articles
[Yishan Wu]'s Articles
[Yishan Wu (E-mail: wuyishan@istic.ac.cn).]'s Articles
Terms of Use
No data!
Social Bookmark/Share
File name: 20160105.pdf
Format: Adobe PDF
All comments (0)
No comment.
 

Items in the repository are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.